Why Jordan Chiles Had to Return Her Olympic^® Medal

The world of gymnastics is full of drama, both on and off the mat, and the controversy surrounding USA gymnast Jordan Chiles' bronze medal in the 2024 Olympic^® women's floor exercise final is no exception. Unlike most cases where athletes return medals due to doping violations, Chiles' situation revolves around a timing dispute related to a scoring inquiry. Join us as we unpack why Jordan Chiles had to give back her medal and the subsequent fallout.

Jordan Chiles at the US Championships, 2024. Photo courtesy of Ocoudis, under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Chiles Wins Bronze

Jordan Chiles, a standout member of the USA Gymnastics team and the last gymnast to compete in the women's floor exercise final at the 2024 Olympics^®, originally finished fifth in the event. However, an appeal by her coach Cecile Landi led to her score being revised by 0.1 points, moving her up to third place and earning her the bronze medal. The win was historic as it marked the first time all three positions on the Olympic podium were held by Black women.

Chiles' upgraded score bumped Romanian gymnast Ana Bărbosu off the podium, which triggered an appeal from the Romanian Gymnastics Federation. They argued that the USA Gymnastics inquiry into Chiles' score was submitted too late, beyond the one-minute window allowed for such appeals.

The Romanian Challenge

The rules of the International Gymnastics Federation (FIG) are clear: a coach must file a verbal inquiry within 60 seconds of the score being posted for the last gymnast in a rotation. The Romanian team claimed that the USA Gymnastics inquiry was submitted four seconds after the deadline, rendering it invalid. As a result, they argued that Chiles' initial score of 13.666 should stand, which would place Bărbosu in third and Chiles in fifth.

This dispute was brought before the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), where both sides presented their cases. The CAS ruled in favor of Romania, stating that the inquiry by USA Gymnastics was indeed submitted after the allowed timeframe, and therefore Chiles' score should not have been revised. Consequently, Chiles was stripped of her bronze medal, and it was awarded to Bărbosu.

USA Gymnastics' Response and the Fallout

The decision to revoke Chiles' medal sparked outrage among fans and supporters. USA Gymnastics and the U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee (USOPC) expressed their disappointment, stating that they firmly believed Chiles rightfully earned the bronze medal. They highlighted concerns about the fairness of the process but did not provide specific details of the CAS decision during their initial response.

In an attempt to overturn the decision, USA Gymnastics submitted timestamped video evidence showing that the inquiry was made within 47 seconds of the score being posted. However, the CAS maintained that once a decision is finalized, it cannot be reconsidered, even if new evidence becomes known.

The controversy took a toll on Chiles, who faced harsh criticism on social media. In response, she decided to take a break from social media for her mental health, expressing her heartbreak over the situation.

A Rare Case in Olympic History

Jordan Chiles' case is unique in Olympic history. Most instances of athletes returning their medals involve doping violations or other forms of cheating. Chiles, however, had to give back her medal due to a technicality involving the timing of a score inquiry — a rare and unfortunate circumstance.

While the appeal process continues, with USA Gymnastics vowing to pursue every possible avenue to restore Chiles' medal, the outcome remains uncertain. What is clear, however, is that this incident has highlighted the need for more transparency and consistency in how scoring disputes are handled in international sports.

Jordan Chiles' story is a reminder of the complexities and pressures athletes face, not only in their performances but also in the administrative and regulatory aspects of their sport. As the appeal process unfolds, one can only hope that the system will become more fair and more transparent, ensuring that athletes like Chiles receive the recognition they deserve.

References: Everything to know about the controversy over Jordan Chiles' Olympic bronze medal | Jordan Chiles' case is unusual. Most returned Olympic medals are for cheating.